“It Can’t Happen Here” Predicted Trump In 1935

May 13, 2018

It’s not often that I read and review fiction, but with the Trump presidency devolving into a desperate, rabid beast it was time to read “It Can’t Happen Here” by Sinclair Lewis.
The book, which was written in 1935 as Fascism was rising in Europe, accurately predicted the rise of an authoritarian like Mein Trumpf.

Let’s begin with an overview of the story-line and then get into a few specifics:

The two main opposed characters are small town Vermont newspaper publisher Doremus Jessup, and eventual dictator Berzelius “Buzz” Windrip. Windrip is fashioned somewhat in the likes of Huey Long, a barnstorming Democrat in the populist vein. He promises an orderly “chicken in every pot” working man’s utopia, cloaking the emerging movement in a militia structure that seems to operate independently of political control. Windrip has written his manifesto “Zero Hour” in which he outlines his philosophy to the masses.

Meanwhile, back in sleepy Vermont, newspaper editor Doremus Jessup watches cautiously as Windrip firms up what is becoming his dictatorship. It is in this realm that author Sinclair Lewis paints a broad picture of the town and it’s residents. In fact, he loads us up with so many individuals it slows the plot down a bit. Honestly, it took almost 200 pages to get to the meat of the story but Lewis really finds his voice and the novel shifts into serious action. Or at least as much action as you can find in a sleepy Vermont town. The dictatorship clamps down on border crossings, and an escape to Canada by Doremus and his family is foiled. His newspaper is seized, but among executions of dissidents Doremus and his cohorts start an underground paper and begin organizing resistance cells.

Without giving away the plot, I can only say Sinclair Lewis leaves the conclusion somewhat unresolved, placing the responsibility and outcome on the people, and the same kind of resistance experienced by over half our country in the era of Trump.

Here are some uncanny similarities between Windrip and Trump:

* Trump had his TV show and (supposedly) wrote “The Art Of The Deal”
Windrip was a blustery barnstorming speaker who wrote “Zero Hour”.

* (Windrip) was certain that some day America would have vast business dealings with the Russians…
(page 27, Signet Classics version)
The Russiagate investigation of Trump is outlining some very dubious financial dealings.

* Windrip attacks the press: “I know the press only too well. Almost all editors hide away in spider dens…” (Chapter 5)
Trump is constantly attacking the press, threatening to pull their credentials.

* Windrip had “The League of Forgotten Men”. Trump has “The Alt-Right”.

* Sign at Windrip rally “We are on relief. We want to become human beings again. We Want Buzz!”
Signs at Trump Rally: “Make America Great Again”.

* “When Buzz gets in, he won’t have any parade of wounded soldiers. That’ll be bad Fascist psychology”.
Starting with the G.W. Bush administration, taking pictures of soldiers coffins was forbidden.

* Windrips wide-ranging plan for Fascism includes financial and manufacturing control, building a larger military, and most significantly “All Negroes shall be prohibited from voting, holding public office, practicing law, medicine or teaching…” (P. 63)
Trump is obsessed with race, a southern border fence, and travel bans for people from certain countries. Trump is issuing broad mandates on trade and manufacturing.

* Sinclair writes; “…that all well-paying jobs and businesses held by Negroes will be grabbed by the Poor White Trash among Buzz’s worshipers…”
Trump promises to bring jobs back to his “poor white trash” worshipers.

* Speaking about Windrip (P. 71); “…his power of bewitching large audiences, The Senator was vulgar, almost illiterate, a public liar easily detected, And in his “ideas” as almost idiotic, while his celebrated piety was that of a traveling salesman for church furniture, and his yet more celebrated humor the sly cynicism of a country store.”
Well, that’s pure Trump in a nutshell.

* Like Trump, Windrip proudly brags about being ignorant (P. 84)
Trump at rally: “I love the uninformed”.

* Mirroring the current investigation into Russian election meddling:
“Why, can’t you see, if the Communists had paid for it they couldn’t have had anything more elegant for our purposes than the election of a pro-plutocrat, itching militarist dictator like Buzz Windrip!” (P. 107)

* Windrip has a paramilitary called “The Minutemen”. The term dates back to the American revolution, but more recently was known as an armed, militant off-shoot of John Birch Society ideology.
Trump has his “alt-right” thugs and armed militia groups that have been a presence at recent demonstrations.


I could go on and on. It seems the patterns associated with fascism repeat themselves over and over, in multiple versions of society. The populist appeal, the bait-and-switch, the disappointment leading to the scapegoating of a given underclass, and violence.

“It Can’t Happen Here” was a bit of a difficult read at the beginning. It’s a little overloaded with names of characters that are only tangentially involved and has line after line of old-time Vermont witticisms. But I am really, really glad I read it, the second half totally grabbed my attention. The version I got was a smaller Signet Classics pocketbook. I bought another for a friend that was in larger scale and print.
If you can wade through some archaic language, if you care to marvel at how spot-on Lewis was in this prophetic tale, this book will teach us a lot.

I’d like to close with this lengthy quote:

(Doremus) “He was afraid that the world struggle today was not of Communism against Fascism, but of tolerance against the bigotry that was preached equally by Communism and Fascism. But he saw too that in America the struggle was befogged by the fact that the worst Fascists were they who disowned the word “Fascism” and preached enslavement to Capitalism under the style of Constitutional and Traditional Native American Liberty. For they were thieves not only of wages but of honor. To their purpose they could quote not only Scripture but Jefferson”.

Share Button

Tags: , , ,

2 Responses to “It Can’t Happen Here” Predicted Trump In 1935

  1. Tex on May 14, 2018 at 11:59 pm

    It is often the case that the only difference between fiction and fact is the passing of time.

  2. Bruce on May 15, 2018 at 12:26 am

    “without giving away the plot”!!!! John, the book was written in 1935! I think the plot and anything else in the book is safe since you are the last person to read the book in 50 years. History repeating itself. There are few true historians left and fewer still people who listen to them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Live Traffic Feed

Free Visitor Tracking Widget



RSS Northwest Research & Covert Book Report

  • Review: The Hidden History Of The Human Race
    As the plague season rolls on, my reading has (as a matter of sanity) drifted from hard-core political filth to more esoteric subjects. They have been quite a welcome distraction. For instance, I recently reviewed “Daydream Sunset” by Ron Jacobs, about counterculture in the 1970’s. (All reviews can be found at https://www.covertbookreport.com/ ) Then we […]
  • George And Barbara, A Couple Of Real Turkeys
    Flock of turkeys currently stalking our road *** Many years ago I was the caretaker of a 300-acre farm on the Columbia River in Oregon. The farms in the area were very isolated, with tons of wildlife. I planted corn and millet for game feed and the owners occasionally hunted there. Meanwhile, I grew huge […]
  • Review: “Surveillance Valley” By Yasha Levine
    Once in a while a book comes long that smacks you in the head and says: “This is whats really going on”. “Surveillance Valley – The Secret Military History Of The Internet” – by Yasha Levine, is just such a book. We live in an age of technical wonder, a quasi-magical age where information is […]
  • Review: “Breath” By James Nestor
    Review: “Breath” by James Nestor Every now and then I come across a book that I claim is the most important book I have read this year. Of course, I sometimes say that two or three times a year. However, one such book is “Breath – The New Science Of A Lost Art”, by James […]
  • Review: The Hunt For Zero Point – By Nick Cook
    In an effort to get a little distance from hardcore politics and history, I recently reviewed a book on the counterculture in the ’70’s and a great book on Bigfoot. Now comes a book on government research into antigravity and the “flying saucer” phenomenon. “The Hunt For Zero Point – Inside The Classified World Of […]